IPL 2025 Umpiring Controversies Affecting Indian Stars Like Rohit Sharma
The 2025 edition of the Indian Premier League (IPL) has been a thrilling showcase of cricketing excellence, featuring explosive batting, strategic bowling, and unforgettable finishes. However, alongside the on-field brilliance, the tournament has also witnessed a series of umpiring controversies, many of which have directly impacted prominent Indian cricketers. At the center of much discussion has been Rohit Sharma, whose frustration with several questionable decisions has reignited debates around umpiring standards and the role of technology in the game.
The Spark: A Crucial Dismissal
The controversy took shape during a high-stakes match between Mumbai Indians and Royal Challengers Bengaluru, when Rohit Sharma, opening the innings, was adjudged LBW on a delivery that appeared to be missing leg stump. Despite having a review available, Rohit chose not to use the Decision Review System (DRS), showing faith in the on-field umpire’s call. Replays later showed that the ball had pitched outside leg stump, and the decision could have easily been overturned.
The incident became a flashpoint, with fans, former cricketers, and analysts expressing concern over such pivotal moments being marred by human error. For Rohit Sharma, a player known for his calm demeanor, this was not an isolated case in IPL 2025.
Repeated Errors: A Pattern Emerging
Within the span of just a few weeks, multiple incidents involving questionable calls against Rohit and other senior Indian players added fuel to the fire. In a match against Lucknow Super Giants, Rohit was again at the receiving end of a marginal caught-behind decision. Though the ultra-edge replay showed inconclusive contact between bat and ball, the on-field decision stood in favor of the fielding side.
These recurring incidents led to growing murmurs from inside the dressing rooms. Several franchise sources hinted at dissatisfaction with inconsistencies in umpiring, especially when high-profile matches were affected.
Technology vs. Human Judgment
IPL 2025 has seen a broader conversation emerge about the limitations of current technology and the pressure on umpires in high-pressure games. While the tournament uses DRS, ball-tracking, ultra-edge, and stump mics, the final authority still rests with human decision-makers, which leaves room for interpretation and error.
Experts argue that the current structure, where umpires must make rapid judgments in fast-paced conditions, often leads to mistakes, especially with complex dismissals like faint edges or ball-tracking misreads.
Former cricketer and commentator Aakash Chopra voiced his opinion during a post-match analysis, stating,
“The game needs to evolve with time. If a batsman like Rohit Sharma is getting out to wrong calls repeatedly, we need to ask whether the systems are good enough to protect the spirit of fair play.”
Impact on Indian Players
While Rohit Sharma has been the most vocal and visible face of these controversies, other Indian players have also been affected. Ruturaj Gaikwad, Virat Kohli, and Shubman Gill have all experienced questionable decisions during the season, some of which had a direct impact on match outcomes.
The IPL has always been a pressure cooker of expectations, especially for Indian stars under the scrutiny of fans and media. Being dismissed due to umpiring errors not only affects individual performances but also the momentum of entire teams.
Franchises like Mumbai Indians and Gujarat Titans reportedly submitted feedback to the IPL governing council, requesting a review of umpiring performance across the season and proposing better accountability mechanisms.
The BCCI’s Position
The Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI), which oversees the IPL, has acknowledged the growing dissatisfaction. In an internal review meeting held in May 2025, the BCCI is believed to have discussed potential upgrades to umpiring tools and training programs. However, no official statement has been released regarding the incidents involving Rohit Sharma or any other player.
As per tournament rules, umpires are evaluated after every game, and multiple low scores can result in demotion. Still, critics argue that post-match assessments aren’t enough to protect the integrity of real-time decisions.
What Lies Ahead
As the playoffs approach, the spotlight on umpiring will only intensify. Fans are hoping that better measures will be taken in the future to ensure that iconic players like Rohit Sharma are not denied fair opportunities due to avoidable errors.
Whether through improved technology, more consistent umpiring standards, or clearer communication, there is a strong call within the cricketing community for reform. For a league that prides itself on being the most professional and entertaining cricket tournament globally, accuracy and fairness must remain non-negotiable pillars of its continued success.
.